在大約三年前 (2018 年年初) 的時候，在讀完 Spectre 之後寫下了一些記錄：「讀書時間：Spectre 的攻擊方式」，結果在 Bruce Schneier 這邊看到消息，Google 前幾天把把 PoC 放出來了：「Exploiting Spectre Over the Internet」，在 Hacker News 上也有討論：「A Spectre proof-of-concept for a Spectre-proof web (googleblog.com)」。
首先是這個攻擊方法在目前的瀏覽器都還有用，而且包括 Apple M1 上都可以跑：
The demonstration website can leak data at a speed of 1kB/s when running on Chrome 88 on an Intel Skylake CPU. Note that the code will likely require minor modifications to apply to other CPUs or browser versions; however, in our tests the attack was successful on several other processors, including the Apple M1 ARM CPU, without any major changes.
即使目前的瀏覽器都已經把 performance.now() 改為 1ms 的精度，也還是可以達到 60 bytes/sec 的速度：
While experimenting, we also developed other PoCs with different properties. Some examples include:
- A PoC which can leak 8kB/s of data at a cost of reduced stability using performance.now() as a timer with 5μs precision.
- A PoC which leaks data at 60B/s using timers with a precision of 1ms or worse.
比較苦的消息是 Google 已經確認在軟體層沒辦法解乾淨，目前在瀏覽器上只能靠各種 isolation 降低風險，像是將不同站台跑在不同的 process 裡面：
In 2019, the team responsible for V8, Chrome’s JavaScript engine, published a blog post and whitepaper concluding that such attacks can’t be reliably mitigated at the software level. Instead, robust solutions to these issues require security boundaries in applications such as web browsers to be aligned with low-level primitives, for example process-based isolation.
Apple M1 也中這件事情讓人比較意外一點，看起來是當初開發的時候沒評估？目前傳言的 M1x 與 M2 不知道會怎樣...
