Tag: black

Black 是一套 Python 上的 Code Formatter，可以幫你重排程式碼以符合 coding style 與 coding standard，比起只是告訴你哪邊有錯來的更進階...

記得以前好像不是掛在官方帳號下面的，翻了一下發現在 Hacker News 上的「https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17151813」這則可以看到，去年在 ambv 的 repository 上，現在則是被導到 python 的組織下了 :o

目前還是掛 beta，另外有不少 practice 讓人不太舒服，像是 Hacker News 上「https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19939806」這邊提到的：

Against my better judgment I'll bite.
I super dislike black's formatting, and I think it's really rare to actually see it in codebases. It wraps weirdly (sometimes not at all). I'd prefer to use yapf, but last I checked it still crashes on "f-strings".

Here's a small example:

    basket.add({
        apple.stem
        for satchel in satchels
        for apple in satchel
    })
Black formats this as:
    basket.add(
        {
            apple.stem
            for satchel in satchels
            for apple in satchel
        }
    )
        
I've never seen Python code like that.
I totally believe using a formatter is good practice. Black is in a challenging position of coming into a community with a lot of existing code and customs, and I get that. But I also think that's an opportunity, rather than having to guess at what is good, there's a wealth of prior art to look at. I wish it had done this, rather than essentially codify the author's style.

看起來還有很多可以調整的，然後也可以考慮用看看... 以前是 3rd-party 還可以丟著不管，現在帶有官方色彩得看一下 :o